Skip to main content

Selecting a Poet: Ohio Poetry Day's Process



“I've been an Ohioan my whole life, and I'm honored to be recognized in my home state,” says Maggie Smith, the newly crowned Ohio Poet of the Year. A big congratulations is certainly due for this wonderful accomplishment, awarded by the Ohio Poetry Day (OPD) Association.

    Started in 1938, this non-profit organization is interested in promoting quality writing, often through its blog, chapbooks, and contests. Long-standing member Amy Jo Zook, who functions as both treasurer and contest chairman for OPD, graciously shared the process of selecting a winner. 

These books can be nominated by any well-read person, and mostly come from publishers, literary groups or organizations, libraries, or independent sources such as friends and family. A poet may never nominate oneself and will likely not know of their nomination unless told by the nominator, or until they win the title of Ohio Poet of the Year. Similarly, Smith stated “...I honestly [knew] nothing about it. I did not know my book and I [were] being considered. I received a call while on vacation... informing me that I was selected as Ohio Poet of the Year for The Well Speaks of Its Own Poison, and I was delighted, of course.” 

As one can imagine, there are quite a few choices to narrow down, typically into a selection of four to eight books. This is the set that the judges, members of OPD who are handpicked each year, examine. 

When asked what the judges hope to see, Zook replied that the best pick is “neither too simplistic nor too abstract.” The book should be recently published, so as “to best capture the poet’s current style.” Like Smith’s work, many of the past winners’ books contain poems about or related to Ohio, but this is not required. However, and understandably so, it must be of high quality. Zook added that “the goal is to find something accessible to a large audience,” something challenging in content that would make the reader crave more of the poet’s work.

The judges then vote after comparing all the choices, and this step is done individually. Zook believes that, by waiting until after voting to discuss the poetry with the other judges, the final pick does not become a compromise. Instead, the election is more clean and clear. 

And so the election this year led to Maggie Smith, who says her book “...was largely inspired by fairy tales and folklore, but it blends those influences with my Ohio roots.”

“Many of the poems are set in or reference places that are important to me, including my childhood home in Westerville, Alum Creek, and Schiller Park in German Village,” she explains. No doubt some of these poems will feel familiar to Ohio readers! 

To hear Maggie Smith’s luncheon reading and speech, come join Ohio Poetry Day at Heidelberg University on October 15 for the award ceremony. The Well Speaks of Its Own Poison and her other publications will also be sold there. If your interest is peaked for more of Maggie’s poetry, please visit her website maggiesmithpoet.com

For more information on Ohio Poetry Day 2016, see the following articles on the OPA blog:   

Written by Logan Morales

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Poetry Spotlight: Karen Schubert - Poetry of Hybridity (podcast transcript S2, E4)

Jeremy Jusek: Welcome to Poetry Spotlight presented by the Ohio Poetry Association. I am your host, Jeremy Jusek. And with us today is Karen Schubert. Karen Schubert Karen is an author, co-founding director of Literary Youngstown, and multi-genre talented writer who has published poetry, fiction, creative nonfiction, essays, reviews, interviews, and any other views you might consider. She's published six books, and her prose poem collection I Left My Winds on a Chair was the Wick Poetry Center poetry winner. Her awards include the William Dickey Memorial Broadside Award, an Ohio Arts Council Individual Excellence Award in Poetry, and has held residencies at the Headlands Center for the Arts and the Vermont Studio Center. To learn more about Karen, please visit karenschubertpoetry.com . Karen, thank you so much for joining us. Karen Schubert: Oh this is such a kick, thanks so much for bringing me on. I’m honored and chuffed. JJ: Thank you! The pleasure’s all mine. Do you wa...

2026 Ohio Poetry Day Contests Now Open for Submissions

Our friends at the Ohio Poetry Day Association have announced their annual contests!  May 15, 2026, is the deadline (postmark)  for two dozen contest categories. Categories include humor, formal poems, parody and more. As always, a “Welcome Aboard” category for first-time submitters and an art category to design the cover art for the 2026  Best of Ohio Poetry Day  anthology are also open to submissions.  Below is a copy of the submission form, which provides full contest information.  Ohio Poetry Day 2026 will take place in October in Toledo, Ohio. Stay up to date on event information, including the event date, location, and agenda, by getting your name and address on the OPD mailing list. To do so, contact: Amy Jo Zook 3520 State Route 56 Mechanicsburg, OH 43044 Checks for all contest fees and purchases should be made payable to: Ohio Poetry Day . For questions, call (937) 834-2666. Click and download the image below to view it at full size.

Odes of October 2025 Contest Winners Announced

OPA is pleased to announce the following winners in its 2025 Odes of October contest. First prize is awarded for "Lemons in the Seventeenth Century," by Marci Rich. First prize includes an award of $65 and inclusion in the 2026 issue of Common Threads, as well being published below. Second prize goes to John Hunt for his poem, "Only the Blues." This prize includes an award of $25, will be published in the 2026 issue of Common Threads, and appears below. Third prize goes to Jonathan Smith for "40 Leaves.". This prize includes an award of $10, will be published in the 2026 issue of Common Threads, and appears below. This year, the judge also chose four poems for Honorable Mention: Shirley Valencia's poem, "Oblivion" Rosalie Hendon's poem, "Penelope to Odysseus" Jo Anne Moser Gibbon's poem, "I Contain Multitudes" Jonathan Smith's poem, "Where Jane Goodall Stood" Sincerest than...